Skip to content
Morotune
LIVE
ABOUT KULIS · News

Turning knobs, but the sound doesn't change: the pre-recorded set debate

10 Nov 2026

In April 2026, an account called LoudLife shared videos from Holy Priest's Lisbon set. The claim was clear: the set had been recorded in advance and the DJ was only turning knobs for show. The videos spread fast and reignited one of electronic music's oldest debates.

What did Holy Priest say?

Holy Priest denied the accusation. According to him, the set was backed by weeks of preparation, edits he made himself and transitions done live. He accepted that recordings may be used at big shows where everything runs in sync with lights and pyro down to the second, but said that was not the case with his own set.

deadmau5's admission

In the background of the debate is a statement deadmau5 made years ago. deadmau5 openly said that he too plays pre-recorded sets. In his view, big festivals effectively require it; giant screens, lights and effects have to match the music exactly. That's why, he argued, it's unfair to call these DJs "not real".

There's also a tell often mentioned in this debate: if the lights and visuals land on the music to the second, the set has most likely been prepared in advance.

The opposing view

The other side's argument is strong too: DJing is live mixing. Choosing the track in the moment, beatmatching, reading the crowd's energy and shaping the set around it are the essence of the job. Turning knobs over a pre-recorded set requires none of these skills.

So what do you think: if there's a big show, is a recording acceptable?

Sources: Hotpress (April 2026), MusicTech (August 2023).

More stories

→ See all
ABOUT EVENTS RADIO OMELO PNIGHT SESSION
OMELO P – Omeloncholia Radio #002