A rave in a 1,600-year-old monastery: the clip that blew up at Sumela, and the set that was applauded in Cappadocia
16 Nov 2026
Electronic music plays inside the 1,600-year-old Sumela Monastery, carved into the cliffs of Maçka in Trabzon, while a crew dances in the courtyard. Within days of appearing on social media in February 2022, the footage turned into an investigation in Ankara and an official protest in Athens. Around the same time, DJ sets filmed in Cappadocia, at Mount Nemrut and in Egyptian temples were watched millions of times and celebrated. So where is the difference?
They waited for snow
Sumela was closed to visitors for restoration at the time. DJ Ahmet Şenterzi and his colleagues Volkan Gündüz and Cengiz Can Atasoy entered the monastery with special permission from the Trabzon Governor's Office and the Provincial Directorate of Culture and Tourism. The 30-strong crew set up a sound system and cameras in the courtyard and filmed themselves dancing to electronic music.
Şenterzi's defence was clear: "We aimed to introduce Sumela to the world from a different perspective and with the energy of music." He said they had specifically waited for snow and taken every measure for sound and safety. The crew's application cited similar clips shot at the Abbey of Bernay in France, the Pyramids of Egypt, and Cappadocia, Nemrut and Göbekli Tepe in Turkey.
Athens rose up
The footage drew a strong reaction in Greece. The Greek Foreign Ministry called it "offensive" and "a desecration" of the monument. Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew wrote to Turkey's Ministry of Culture and Tourism, and President Katerina Sakellaropoulou and the Holy Synod of the Church of Greece also reacted. Greek media reported it as a "rave party".
That is where Sumela's sensitivity lies: today it is a museum under the Ministry of Culture and Tourism, but it remains sacred to the Orthodox world. In 2010, a liturgy was held there for the first time in 88 years; since then, apart from restoration periods, a one-day service has been allowed every 15 August, the Dormition of the Virgin Mary.
Ankara opened an investigation
There was a backlash in Turkey too. The Ministry of Culture and Tourism launched an investigation into the officials who allowed the shoot. It found that permission had been granted without consulting the ministry, on the favourable opinion of a deputy director and the approval of a deputy governor. In the end, the acting Provincial Director of Culture and Tourism, who was on assignment in Spain at the time, was removed from his post on the grounds that permission had been given without ministry approval.
But in Cappadocia, it was applauded
DJ sets at historic sites are nothing new; they are one of electronic music's most-watched formats. In 2020, Paris-based Cercle broadcast Ben Böhmer playing a sunrise set from a hot air balloon over Cappadocia, a UNESCO World Heritage Site. The event was supported by Go Türkiye, Turkey's official tourism promotion brand, and Böhmer even wrote a track called "Cappadocia" for the occasion.
Temples became stages
Jean-Michel Jarre played a huge millennium concert at the Pyramids of Giza on the night of 31 December 1999 into 1 January 2000, invited by the Egyptian state as a UNESCO ambassador. Cercle followed the same path: Adriatique played from the Temple of Hatshepsut in Luxor, and WhoMadeWho from the temples of Abu Simbel.
From Petra to Nemrut
Bedouin played in Petra, Jordan, in front of the rock-cut Al-Khazneh (the Treasury). Be Svendsen played a sunrise set on Mount Nemrut, among the giant stone heads.
Châteaux and cathedrals
Carl Cox played in front of the Château de Chambord in France. Jean-Michel Jarre "played" Notre-Dame to welcome 2021, without entering the cathedral: in a concert produced by the City of Paris under UNESCO patronage, Jarre performed from a nearby studio while his avatar played inside a virtual replica of Notre-Dame.
Where is the difference?
The differences between these examples and Sumela come down to three things:
- What the place means: Cappadocia and Petra are historic heritage sites; Sumela is still sacred to a faith community and hosts an annual liturgy.
- The permit process: Cercle sets are made through official processes with state bodies and tourism authorities. The Sumela permit was issued without consulting the ministry.
- History and timing: Sumela is a sensitive symbol in Turkish–Greek relations. Footage that would count as promotion elsewhere was read here as a political message.
Should historic sites open up to electronic music, or should some places stay off-limits to any kind of event? Is the line drawn by the place itself, by the permit, or by the intention?
Sources: DHA, Sözcü, Medyascope, Euronews, Middle East Eye, Protothema, Cercle, Jean-Michel Jarre